28 January 2023

Mt. Diablo Adult Education - Wood Working 1 (MDAE WW1)

 In the Fall of 2022, I enrolled in the local adult education program to take an evening class in woodworking.  Mt. Diablo has all kinds of great classes and my wife and I will likely take a bunch more over time.

The class I took was "Woodworking 1".  It's the first class and upon completion of WW1 and WW2, you can then take any of the other woodworking classes.  What I liked about the class was two-fold:  it was going to teach me how to use the machines, it cost virtually nothing (ca. $250 for 10 weeks; materials I bought would be extra).  In my home shop, I really don't have much in terms of machines.  I don't want or feel I need a bunch of machines as I like using hand tools because, well, I enjoy the fine skill I get to develop over time.  It became important to me when I stopped working in the lab as a chemist (working with my hands) and became "middle management." Still, I wanted to learn how to safely use them and this seemed like a great way to do so.

The project was a step stool.  Always hand to have a step stool in the home.  Three or four years ago, I made Christan Becksvoort's shaker step stool and my daughter loved to use in; initially as a step stool and later as a chair when she ate food while watching TV.  This step stool would be a bit taller which is good as she has grown quite a bit so something a few inches taller would be helpful.











Construction of the chair was relatively straightforward.  I used Paduk and curly maple for the chair and shellac and wax to finish it.  The wood choices were a driven by what I could find at Rockler before the class.  I had never worked with Paduk before so it was fun to try out a different wood.  It behaves a lot like walnut with hand tools.  It is a really pretty orange and has a nice spicy chocolate scent when planed.  It looks beautiful when finished.  The only thing I didn't like about it was the orange dust that it would leave behind.  Also, with shellac, some color would leach out.  I kept this all in mind when doing the finishing work.




I liked some of the tools, disliked some, and was a bit indifferent to others.  Mostly, that's what I want to discuss as the construction was straightforward (thought that doesn't mean I didn't have to think a bit for parts of it).


Jointer 

They had a nice one - a Powermatic.  In fact most of their tools were nice and they do upgrade on a regular basis.  I didn't really enjoy using it.  Mostly, I don't like the potential risk for serious bodily injury.  In theory, if you do it right, it can be safe.  Sorry, it just raises my stress level at the moment.  I supposed with a powerfeeder that might make it feel safe.  Not in any rush to own one for home.


Planer/Thicknesser

The two of them: a 15" and 24" PowerMatic.  I really liked these machines.  I felt reasonable safe using them.  My biggest struggle working with handtools is getting the wood to desired thickness.  It take a lot of effort by hand and at times I've used wood that has been thicker than I'd like.  When I finished my formal project for the quarter, we were allowed to do other things until the quarter ended.  I brough in some wood for upcomming projects that needed to be thicknessed.  What would have taken me a full weekend of work, I did in a matter of 30 minutes (I am slow by the way).  Now, speed is not my primary goal in woodworking but, I'd like to have a way to get past some of the donkey work.  As such, I ended up getting a DeWalt 735 when it had a Thanksgiving Black Friday sale.  Been happy with it the few times I've used it.  I also know there is a way to use a sled at home to get it to act like a jointer if I need it.






Table Saw

They had a Saw Stop.  Truth be told, I really like the safety features of this tool.  Kind of wish Saw Stop had a larger line of tool types with this technology.  If so, I would buy them.  I would say I'm indifferent to this machine.  It really came in handy for some work I did where I needed to make a bunch of repetitive cuts for a time sensitive Christmas gift I am making.  I don't mind cross cutting by hand or ripping 1" stock by hand.  I have ripped 2" thick stock by hand and don't enjoy that so I definitely need a machine to help with that but the next tool can do that - bandsaw.



BandSaw

I've been wanting a bandsaw for a long time.  I could make long rips in thick wood or resaw thick wood for design consideration.  They had a variety of bandsaws at the school - Delta, Powermatic, and Laguna.  I was happy with all of them.  I did some resawing as well curve cuts with a bandsaw and I felt reasonably comfortable with using it.  When Powermatic had a 10% off sale over Black Friday, I bought their PM1500 bandsaw.  I need to set it up but have a few woodworking things to do first.  Plus, it weighs 400 lbs.  I have a nice way to get it off the pallet and onto the rolling base when I get to it.

Both the planer and bandsaw I purchased will trigger the need for proper dust collection in the shop.  Fortuantely I had been saving for that.  It will be either Oneida or ClearVue.  Honestly just waiting for either of them to have a 10% off sale.  Since I really don' need either tool I purchased, I could easily wait a year if I need to.  If there is any upside to the anticipated recession, is I should be able to get a dust collector for a discount.  Also keeping my eye open for used models from Oneida as well.


Drill Press

They had two from PowerMatic.  I liked them.  Then again, I used my dad's drill press from time to time and I knew I would.  I will get one in the near future.  I don't think it will get much use but handy to have one.  Currently on the lookout for a vintage one (art deco era) that has been restored.  


Router - hand held and table mounted.  Didn't enjoy using them at all.  I have no intention of owning one.  I call it, along with the jointer, the spinning blades of death.  Will that limit some of my woodworking options.  Yes.  That's fine.  I'm not into molding (yet) and if I were, I already have an ok set of hollow and round planes needing some light restoration.  As for making grooves, I have Veritas small plough plane and quite a number of blades.  It's a handy tool and I like it.  Also have the Veritas skewed rabet plane as well.


Oscillating spindle sander

It was handy to use when I had made a bunch of band sawn reindeer as donation gifts.  Eventually, I will likely get one at home.  More than likely I will see about getting an inexpensive one for home.  I don't need it that often but I can see making more band sawn reindeer for donations that the school can sell at their holiday boutique.  In that case, less time per unit means I can provide more for the donation if I don't to have to sand them by hand.



Drum sander

They had a Grizzly and are now upgrading to a Powermatic.  It came in handy for a few things.  Felt safe to use.  I don't see myself getting one for home.  I use hand planes and I have found ways (by learning from others) how to plan thin stock ca (1/16 to 1/8" thick) by hand.


Chop Saw

They had the Dewalt one.  I've used my dad's in the past.  I am comfortable using it. I don't intent to get one.  It doesn't take long to cross cut a 12" wide board by hand and I actually like doing it.  After 7 years, I can saw by had reasonably well so it's not like the chop saw will produce a better cut.  Again, I'm not a production shop.  If I have to make a half dozen to dozen cross cuts on rough stock on a weekend that would be about the max I ever need to do at once.


Handheld rotary sander

They had one.  I didn't use it.  I use my hand planes for almost all of my final smoothing of the wood and a little bit of sand paper if I have curves or round overs to smooth out.  As such, I just don't see the need for one at home.  


Table top mortiser.  

The school had one but we didn't need to use it.  I have one at home, a Powermatic.  I didn't feel confident in my ability to make a good mortise and bought one.  I like it.  At first I "needed" it to get a decent mortise.  Since then, I've learned how to do a mortise by hand.  As such, unless I have a lot of mortises I need to do, I prefer to do them by hand.  For me, the whole woodworking journey was to develop the hand skills.  I really liked my days as an active bench chemist doing highly skilled technical work.  I am very good at my management roll, but, I wonder if I had to do it over again if I would have left the bench.  Then again, almost all of my peers in grad school, who stayed techinal, ended up no longer working at the bench as most reached a level where managing those who were at the bench became their job.  As such, I may not as easily had a choice.  Well, that's crap the more I think about it.  We all have choices we can make or not make.  I just don't think I gave it as much thought and most folks don't.  That's ok I have woodworking now to work on my hand skills and at the end of it, I have nice furniture that I likely couldn't afford to purchase.




All in all, very happy with the MDAE WW1 experience.  I like the instructor and the school and the teaching assistants.  It's a good place to be.  So much so, I am now taking woodworking 2.  Enjoying it as well. They have woodcarving and woodturning classes as well as other hobbies.  As such, I plan to take a lot of classes over time.  I used to do a bowling league (till bowling started to hurt my hand) and enjoyed the one night out a week.  These classes have that similar feel.  I still enjoy woodworking at home but it's nice to woodworking around others from time to time as well.

4 comments:

  1. HI Joe
    I'm in agreement with you on developing the hand tool skills. Over the years I've used all of these machines and now prefer to use the two at the ends of my arms. I still use my tablesaw but mostly for making repetitive rips. For cross cuts I use the bandsaw or handsaws.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The only project in 7 years where I really appreciated the table saw was when I needed to make the stock for two utensil drawer dividers (time limitations resulted in me only making one as a gift for my wife). It was a lot of wood. I think on the table saw, it took me all of 30 min to cross cut to final length and then rip to final width. Having said that, I could have done the same on a bandsaw.

      I am finding my hands ache more than they used to. When I have my annual physical, I will discuss with the doctor to see if it is indeed arthritis. I know on my left hand (which I had discussed with her two years ago), my left thumb tendon was acting up. Apparently this is fairly common and had a name and she printed out something for me. The recommended easy treatments (rest, anti-inflammatory pain meds, etc) haven't helped so that will for sure need to be looked into. I'm not worried. I write this becuse if I reach a point where my hand truly can't do it anymore, then I can see using machines more. I figure I've got another 20 years before this is a serious issue. I don't think I will peter out from woodwoorking. I am still as much in love with and passionate about chemistry today (even more so) than I was in 1986 when I made the decision I wanted to be a chemist.

      Delete
  2. Hi Joe,
    Like you I am also enjoying a largely non-powered approach to woodworking. The chief exception in my shop is a 13" Hitachi bandsaw. In regard to dust collection, I have found the approach shown by https://stumpynubs.com/supercharge-your-small-shop-dust-collection/ to be of great benefit. This is my interpretation. https://photos.app.goo.gl/rjNyWssUxFizbJbP8

    ReplyDelete